Email: info@certifiedperformance.org
Institute for Performance Management

Performance Appraisal Training for Managers

Appraisals are one part of performance management, not the whole of it.

A performance appraisal is a systematic assessment of how someone is doing their job. It is one part of performance management rather than the whole of it, and treating it as the whole is where most organisations go wrong. The wider discipline is covered in our performance management training, of which appraisals are one module.

This training teaches managers to set objectives that can be assessed, keep evidence through the year, run the appraisal conversation well and act on what it shows.

Appraisal training at a glance

Format
Ten modules online and self-paced, about twelve hours of study, six months to complete
Assessment
Final online exam, 70% pass mark, up to six attempts
Certificate
Awarded on passing the exam, carrying the designation Certified Performance Management Professional (CPMP) from the Institute for Performance Management
Price
USD 950, with no membership or renewal fee
Guarantee
Full refund within 30 days of enrolment, no reason required, as long as you have not gone beyond module 5. See the money back guarantee.
Syllabus
Reviewed and approved by the Industry Advisory Council, nine senior business leaders at organisations including IBM, BP, Dell, HP and Fujitsu
Trial
A full module free before you buy

Try Module 3 free Purchase immediate access

The mistake almost everyone makes

Running the appraisal and the annual pay review as the same conversation is not best practice, and it quietly ruins both. The moment money is on the table, the employee's job is to defend their record rather than examine it, and the development discussion disappears from a meeting that was supposed to be about development.

Separating them costs nothing and changes the conversation completely.

What a good appraisal is made of

Three inputs, used together. The employee's own assessment of their performance, which is where the useful disagreements surface. The manager's assessment, which has to be evidenced rather than remembered. And 360 degree feedback from the people who work alongside them, which catches what a manager cannot see.

What it is for, on both sides

For the employee it should produce feedback they can act on, goals for the period ahead, a clear account of what development they need, and an understanding of how pay decisions get made. Done properly it raises engagement rather than dread.

For the employer it identifies who the strong performers actually are, where capability is thin, and who could step up if a role opened. That last one matters more than it gets credit for: succession planning is mostly just appraisal records read carefully.

Why the annual review is losing ground

Adobe is the case most often cited. In 2012 it replaced the annual review entirely with regular check-in conversations between managers and their teams, on the reasoning that feedback a year late is not feedback. The Chartered Management Institute's case study sets out how it made the change. Plenty of large employers have moved the same way since. The shift is not away from assessment, it is away from saving it all up.

That is a harder discipline to run, not an easier one, because it depends on managers who know what they are doing rather than on a form and a deadline. The same applies to software: AI performance reviews can draft the summary, but the judgement has to come from the manager.

Appraisal, review or evaluation

Organisations use different names for this meeting. Many US companies call it a performance review, and performance evaluation turns up a lot in government and universities. The skills a manager needs don't change with the name on the form, so this is performance review training and performance evaluation training for managers as much as it is appraisal training.

Common appraisal methods

Most appraisal systems use one of a handful of methods, often in combination. Graphic rating scales score the employee against fixed criteria such as quality of work or reliability; they are quick, and prone to every manager rating everyone a four. Management by objectives measures results against goals agreed at the start of the period. Behaviourally anchored rating scales tie each score to a described example of behaviour, which makes ratings more consistent from one manager to the next.

The critical incident method keeps a record of specific good and poor moments through the year, so the conversation rests on evidence rather than memory. Forced ranking, which grades people against each other, has largely fallen out of use because of what it does to teamwork. 360 degree feedback is usually added to one of these rather than used alone.

For when each of these methods began, who developed it and what the research says about its accuracy, see our sourced reference on performance appraisal methods: origins, dates and evidence.

Free templates for the review

The performance review template follows the structure on this page, from objectives and evidence to the development plan. There is also a 360 performance review template for multi-rater feedback, and a performance improvement plan template for when a review shows a gap. For keeping bias out of the ratings, see inclusive performance management.

Learning to do it properly

Appraisals are covered inside the Certificate in Performance Management, our broader performance management training, which deals with preparing for and conducting them, the performance management cycle and where the annual review sits in it, and building performance and development plans with templates you can use.

You can find appraisal courses online for a fraction of USD 950, and if all you need is to get through one review season, one of those may be enough. This course covers the cycle the appraisal sits inside, so the conversation rests on objectives that were set properly and evidence that was kept through the year. It ends in an exam, so the certificate says you know the method, not that you watched the videos. You can open a full module free before deciding, and the 30-day guarantee applies after that.

Who it suits

Anyone who manages direct reports or a team. The material is written primarily for business and industry, though the appraisal content applies equally in government and charity settings.